Building a House: Contractor or Architect First?

A beautiful design is not always one you can build on your budget. That is why the order matters.

It is one of the first questions people ask when they plan a house: should I talk to an architect first, or a contractor? Most assume the answer is obvious. The architect designs the house, and once the drawings are finished, contractors are asked to price and build it.

That sequence sounds sensible. On site, it is often where the biggest problems begin. Our short answer: bring both in early, before the design is fixed. The architect leads the design, and the contractor makes sure the design can be built, is structurally sound and fits your budget.

The budget shapes the design, not the other way round

Every design decision has a price: the floor area, the number of storeys, a basement, column-free spans, facade materials, and the ground beneath it all. If nobody costs the design while it is being developed, the real number only appears when the drawings are finished and the cost estimate is prepared.

At that point the options are all unwelcome. The budget goes far above plan; the design is reworked, with floor area cut, materials changed or details dropped; or the project is cancelled. The design time and fees already spent do not come back.

That is why an honest budget figure is the most important piece of information at the start. We understand that many owners are reluctant to share it, worried the contractor will price up to that number. Yet that figure tells us how large a house is realistic, whether a basement makes sense, and whether long cantilevers, or columns that stop short of the ground and need transfer beams and columns, are affordable. Why sharing it protects you, and how to make sure the price stays fair, is covered in Your House-Building Budget.

Three things we have seen

The examples below involved designs that reached us already finished. Names and locations are left out.

A basement with ordinary brick walls

A house was designed with its ground floor about three metres above the road, and the space below it worked like a basement, buried in soil on all sides. In the design, every wall of that space was drawn as an ordinary brick wall.

A wall that holds back soil, and groundwater if there is any, must be designed as a retaining wall that resists lateral earth and water pressure. An ordinary brick wall is not designed for that. We asked for those walls to be changed to reinforced concrete retaining walls. Technically the correction was essential, but once it was priced, the cost was far above what the owner expected. The project was never built.

A house on a canal

A four-storey house was designed on a plot right on a canal open to the sea, with many rooms and generous floor-to-floor heights. The design followed the owner's wishes, but the site conditions had not been considered.

A plot like this calls for a tall retaining wall along the canal, concrete walls on the water side, and dewatering to keep water out of the work area. Canal setback rules also limit where piles may be driven, so the loads on the canal side have to be carried in a more expensive way. Once all of that was costed, the budget came to about twice what the owner could commit. This project was cancelled too.

There is a lesson here that is rarely discussed. The owner's disappointment fell on whoever delivered the number, even though the number simply reflected a design that had never been costed.

Beautiful in 3D, difficult in reality

Some designs look stunning in 3D renderings but leave technical problems for the builder. One was a house whose sloping walls were its signature, including walls of rooms below road level. All of them were drawn in brick, and even the first structural drawings still showed brick.

We had doubts and asked the structural consultant to re-analyse them. The walls had to become reinforced concrete retaining walls that also carry the building's loads. That owner was ready for the extra cost, and the house was completed well. Had the brick walls been built as drawn, the shortfall would only have shown once the house was standing, when correcting it is far harder and more expensive.

Other things we often find in designs that were only resolved in 3D:

  • A sloping roof running into a wall without proper flashing and gutters. Roof-to-wall junctions are among the most common leak points.
  • Heavy natural stone ceilings. Ceilings are non-structural components, and heavy ceilings can fall on occupants in an earthquake. SNI 1726:2019 covers the seismic design of non-structural components, and FEMA E-74 identifies heavy ceilings as a major hazard.
  • Wet areas that were never planned. Floor drains are requested after the structure is built, when floor falls, recessed bathroom slabs and waterproofing should have been planned before the concrete was poured.

All of these are cheap to solve during design. Found on site, they are expensive to fix and often compromise the look you wanted.

What you gain when the contractor is involved early

In international practice this is known as early contractor involvement: the contractor joins during design to advise on cost, buildability and risk. For a house, the benefits are simple and immediate:

  • Cost visibility from the start, so the floor area, form and specification match your budget before the design is fixed.
  • The ground and foundations are taken into account. In PIK and North Jakarta, foundations can take a large share of the budget, and they can only be estimated with adequate soil data and experience of piling nearby. Rough guesses during design are often far off: for one design with a very long cantilever and concentrated loads, the piles needed were 45 x 45 cm and 38 metres deep, while the early estimate assumed 25 x 25 cm at 18 metres, which might be enough for an ordinary house on the same plot. A gap like that is enough to cancel a project if it only emerges at the end. See Soil Investigation for a House in PIK and Pile Foundations for a House in PIK.
  • Details that can be built well, such as retaining walls, roof junctions, wet areas and service routes, are resolved in the early drawings.
  • Fewer revisions, so design time and fees are not wasted.

This does not mean architects matter less

The architect still leads the design, and a good architect is the most important partner in building a beautiful home. The problem is not the architect but the sequence: a design finished in isolation, then handed over to be priced and built. The best houses come from an architect and a contractor working as one team from the start.

So, whom should you call first?

  • If you don't have an architect yet, call a contractor who works with architects. At Rimba, the design is prepared by our partner architects and the structure by an independent structural consultant, PT Cipta Sukses. You start through one door, and the design is developed with cost, structure and site conditions considered from day one.
  • If you already have an architect, bring the contractor in before the design is fixed, not after the construction drawings are finished. We regularly work with the client's own architect.

What to ask before the design is fixed

  • Is there a cost estimate for this design, and who prepared it?
  • Have the soil conditions and foundation needs been considered?
  • Are walls that hold back soil designed as retaining walls?
  • Are the roof, gutter and wet-area details drawn, not just shown in 3D?
  • Are all costs and fees, including third-party fees, written clearly into the contract?

If you are planning a house in PIK or North Jakarta, tell us about your plot and your plans before the design is fixed. See also building a house in PIK, stage by stage and how we work.

References

  1. Badan Standardisasi Nasional (Indonesian National Standards Agency). SNI 1726:2019 Tata cara perencanaan ketahanan gempa untuk struktur bangunan gedung dan nongedung (Earthquake resistance design for buildings and other structures), including seismic design of non-structural components.
  2. FEMA E-74 (2012). Reducing the Risks of Nonstructural Earthquake Damage: A Practical Guide. Ceilings.
  3. NEC (neccontract.com). Involving contractors early using NEC; NEC4 Option X22 Early Contractor Involvement.
  4. IIBEC. The most common problems with residential counterflashing.
  5. BRANZ / Level. Wet area design: floor falls and floor wastes.

Frequently asked questions

Should I contact an architect or a contractor first when building a house?

Ideally both, early, before the design is fixed. The architect leads the design; the contractor makes sure it can be built, is sound and fits the budget. If you don't have an architect yet, you can start with a contractor who works with partner architects.

Why do designs so often go over budget?

Because the cost is only worked out after the design is finished. Basements, retaining walls, foundations on soft ground or a waterfront plot can add large costs that do not show in a 3D rendering.

What is early contractor involvement?

An approach in which the contractor joins during design to advise on cost, buildability and risk, so the design fits the budget and needs fewer revisions.

Does involving the contractor early mean I don't need an architect?

No. The architect still leads the design. What changes is the sequence: architect and contractor work as one team from the start.

Plan it right from the start

Tell us where your land is, its size, your architect or consultant (if you have one), and when you plan to start. Our team will review it and get back to you.