How to Compare Contractor Quotes for a House in Jakarta

The cheapest quote is not always the cheapest house. How to read one before you sign.

Most owners planning a house in Jakarta ask two or three contractors for a quote. That is the right instinct. The difficulty starts when the totals differ widely and the only thing you can compare is the bottom line.

A large price gap almost always has an explanation. Often it is not that one contractor is more efficient, but that the quotes are not for the same thing: different specifications, work left out, or different quantities. This article explains what to check so that the comparison is fair, and when a price gap deserves a question.

Why one quote can be much cheaper

In the comparison quotes we have seen, the gap usually comes from the items below. Not all of it is bad faith; some contractors simply price from incomplete information. For you, the result is the same: the starting price does not reflect the house you will receive.

Structure below the consultant's design. One example we have come across: the structural consultant's drawings specified piles of 45 x 45 cm driven 38 metres deep, while one quote priced piles of 25 x 25 cm at 18 metres. The price difference is large, and because most owners do not read structural drawings, the difference is invisible.

Work that never appears in the list. Some small but important items are easy to leave out of a quote. Two examples are concrete blinding, and the small reinforced concrete tie-columns and lintels that hold brick walls together.

Blinding is a thin layer of low-grade concrete cast on the ground before the footings, ground beams or slabs. It gives a clean, level base, so that water and cement paste from the structural concrete are not absorbed into the soil and the concrete is not mixed with mud. The concrete can then cure properly and reach the strength of its design mix. It also gives a level seat for the concrete spacers that keep reinforcement at the right distance from the concrete surface.

Tie-columns are small reinforced concrete columns at wall corners and junctions, and usually at the sides of wide door and window openings. A lintel is a small beam above a door or window frame that carries the brickwork above the opening. Without it, that weight bears on the frame and the surrounding bricks, and the corners of the opening are prone to cracking. Together with the ground beam below and the ring beam above, tie-columns also hold the brickwork in confined panels, which resist earthquakes better than unconfined brick walls.[1]

Leave these out and the price falls, but so does the quality of the building.

Work that is "not included". An underground water tank and a septic tank or wastewater treatment system are common examples left out of the price. They still have to be built; their cost simply appears after the contract is signed.

Cheaper construction methods. Some cheaper ways of working lower the quality without ever showing in the quote. One example is casting main structural columns against the brick walls, using the bricks as formwork to save on shuttering. In a reinforced concrete frame, the columns and beams should be cast first in proper formwork, and the walls built afterwards.[2] When dry bricks are used as formwork, they can draw water from the fresh concrete, and the column's size and alignment are hard to control. This is different from the small tie-columns in brick walls, which are normally cast after the brickwork is laid.

Another example is how wall dowels are fixed. Wall dowels are short steel bars that anchor the brickwork to the columns. In houses, and especially in luxury houses, structural columns are usually designed as slim as the structural calculation safely allows, so that they do not project from the walls and the walls do not need thickening. The result is dense reinforcement and a narrow gap between the bars and the formwork. If the dowels are cast in, poking through the formwork, they become one more obstruction in that narrow gap. Coarse aggregate can lodge above them, the concrete below does not fill completely, and the result is honeycombing. This is the same principle behind the concrete standard's limit on aggregate size relative to the clear spacing between bars, which exists so that concrete can flow and fill the whole form.[3] For columns like these, the safer method is to cast the column without dowels, then drill and fix the dowels with a chemical anchor adhesive. Installation must follow the adhesive manufacturer's procedure, especially hole cleaning, embedment depth and curing time, and drilling points must be placed to avoid the column's reinforcement. This method costs more, so it rarely appears in a cheap quote.

None of this is written in the quote, but it determines the quality of the structure you are paying for.

Patterns to watch for

Beyond differences in content, some ways of writing a quote make comparison difficult:

  • Low unit price, inflated quantity. The price per square or cubic metre looks low, but the quantity is larger than needed. This is hard to check when the units are unfamiliar, such as the sloped area of a roof or the volume of concrete in cubic metres.
  • Vague item names. For example, "second floor structure" with no breakdown of concrete, reinforcement and formwork. You cannot tell what is included and what is not.
  • "Or equivalent" specifications. A line such as "Brand A tiles or equivalent" lets the contractor substitute a cheaper material and declare it equivalent.
  • Long footnotes. The list of exclusions and conditions at the bottom of a quote often goes unread, and that is usually where extra costs hide.
  • Agree now, revise later. The contractor agrees to a specification below the consultant's drawings to keep the price low. Once the contract is signed and the down payment made, the work "turns out" to need adjusting, at extra cost.

The last pattern does the most damage. Before you sign, you are free to choose. After you sign and pay the down payment, your negotiating position is much weaker. That is why quotes need to be checked before the contract, not after.

Seven things to check in every quote

  1. The basis of the price. A good quote states which architectural and structural drawings it is priced from, with their dates or revision numbers. If two quotes are priced from different drawings, the numbers cannot be compared.
  2. A bill of quantities (BOQ). Ask for the quantity of every item. Compare quantities for the same item across quotes. If concrete or steel quantities differ widely for the same drawings, ask why.
  3. Itemised breakdown. Each item should be broken down into its parts, for example concrete, reinforcement and formwork priced separately. The more detailed it is, the less room there is for misunderstanding.
  4. Specifications with brands and types. Concrete grade, steel type and bar sizes, and the brands of cement, tiles, paint, pipes and cables should be written clearly. If the word "equivalent" appears, agree in the contract that any substitution must be approved by you in writing before it is installed.
  5. The list of exclusions. Read every footnote. Ask for excluded work to be priced separately, so that you know the real total.
  6. How unit prices are built up. Each contractor sets its own unit prices, but they should be explainable. The usual method is a unit price analysis, which breaks each unit of work into the materials, labour and equipment it needs. The Indonesian government uses this method for public project estimates, under Ministry of Public Works and Housing Regulation No. 8 of 2023.[4]
  7. Schedule and payment terms. A serious quote comes with a construction schedule. Payments should follow progress. As a reference point, Indonesian public procurement caps the down payment and withholds part of each payment as retention, a guarantee during the maintenance period.[5] Private house contracts are not bound by these rules, but the principles are worth borrowing.

The fairest way: one set of documents for every contractor

Comparison is easiest when every contractor prices from the same documents: the same drawings, technical specifications and bill of quantities. Then you are comparing price, not different scopes.

Indonesian building regulations follow the same logic. Government Regulation No. 16 of 2021 states that tender documents for building construction are prepared from the detailed design, which includes at minimum detailed architectural, structural and services drawings, the conditions of contract and technical specifications, the bill of quantities and cost estimate, and the design reports, including the structural calculations and the soil investigation.[6]

If no such package exists yet, at least make sure every contractor receives the same drawing revision, and ask them all to price the same list of items.

Two stories we see repeated

We tell them without names, because the pattern matters more than the people.

The retaining wall. For a house whose plot needed nearly 3 metres of fill, we proposed a sheet pile retaining wall. The owner chose a cheaper quote that used a stone masonry wall instead. Some time later the wall collapsed and damaged the facility behind the plot. A stone masonry wall is a gravity wall, relying on its own weight. The higher the fill it holds back, the wider and heavier the wall must be, and on ground with low bearing capacity, such as soft soil, this type of wall is often unsuitable without careful geotechnical design. The cost of repair and compensation far exceeded the original price difference.

Adding a floor. An owner wanted to add a storey to an existing house. We recommended the proper sequence: assess the existing structure and foundations, add foundations where needed, strengthen the structure, and only then build the new floor. It sounded complicated, and the owner chose a contractor who promised a simpler, cheaper approach. After the contract and down payment, that contractor reported that the existing foundations and structure needed strengthening first. The work came back to the same sequence, but now the owner was already under contract. Note also that adding a floor changes the number of storeys and the floor area, so in Indonesia it requires an amended building permit.[7]

In both cases, the information needed was available before signing. What was missing was a way to compare quotes by what they contain.

How we prepare our quotes

Because we often lose on the bottom line, we prepare our quotes so that they can be checked line by line:

  • Quantities first, then the budget. Quantities are taken from the architectural and structural drawings, and the drawing revisions used are stated on the front page.
  • As detailed as possible. Work is broken down into its parts, with labour and material prices shown separately.
  • Specifications with brands. Every item states its specification and material brand, so nothing can be substituted without your approval.
  • Quantities as built on site. We measure quantities as they are actually needed on site, including reasonable working allowances, not only the theoretical figures from the drawings.
  • Unit prices from a unit price analysis. We can explain where every unit price comes from.
  • A schedule. Our quotes come with a construction schedule.

As a result, our total sometimes looks higher than other quotes. But with a detailed quote you can see exactly what you are paying for, and use the same list to ask other contractors for a like-for-like price. To see how we work from planning to handover, visit how we work.

Summary: a checklist before you sign

  • All quotes are priced from the same drawings and revisions.
  • There is a bill of quantities, and the quantities make sense across quotes.
  • The structural specification matches the structural consultant's drawings, including pile size and depth.
  • Easily omitted items are listed clearly: blinding, tie-columns, lintels, and wall dowels with their diameter, length and spacing.
  • Material specifications state brands and types, and substitutions need written approval.
  • The exclusions have been read and priced.
  • There is a schedule, and payments follow progress.
  • Every question has been answered before the down payment is made.

References

  1. Boen, T. (2005). Constructing Seismic Resistant Masonry Houses in Indonesia. Teddy Boen & Associates and UNCRD. See also Kusumastuti, D., Suarjana, M., et al. (2012). Experimental Study on Typical Confined Masonry Structure under Cyclic Lateral Load. 15th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, Lisbon.
  2. Brzev, S. and Meli, R. (2012). International Guideline for Seismic Design of Low-Rise Confined Masonry Buildings. 15th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, Lisbon.
  3. SNI 2847:2019 Persyaratan Beton Struktural untuk Bangunan Gedung (Structural concrete requirements for buildings), which adopts ACI 318-14: limits on nominal maximum coarse aggregate size relative to clear spacing between bars.
  4. Peraturan Menteri PUPR Nomor 8 Tahun 2023 (Minister of Public Works and Housing Regulation No. 8 of 2023) on guidelines for estimating construction costs.
  5. Peraturan Presiden Nomor 16 Tahun 2018 (Presidential Regulation No. 16 of 2018) on government procurement, as amended, Article 29 (down payment) and Article 53 (retention).
  6. Peraturan Pemerintah Nomor 16 Tahun 2021 (Government Regulation No. 16 of 2021) implementing the Building Law, Article 144.
  7. Peraturan Pemerintah Nomor 16 Tahun 2021, Article 262(2).

Frequently asked questions

Is the cheapest contractor quote always worse?

Not always. A cheap quote can be fair. What matters is that the contents are the same: priced from the same drawings, with the same quantities, specifications and scope. If everything is the same and the price is still lower, the difference may genuinely be efficiency.

What is a bill of quantities (BOQ)?

A bill of quantities lists the quantity of every item of work, such as cubic metres of concrete or kilograms of steel. Multiplied by unit prices, it becomes the priced cost estimate. To compare quotes, the quantities matter as much as the total.

What if a quote says "or equivalent"?

Ask which brand and type are meant, and write into the contract that any material substitution must be approved by the owner in writing before installation.

When should a quote be checked in detail?

Before the contract is signed and before the down payment is made. After that, changes usually come only as variations, and the owner's negotiating position is much weaker.

What down payment is reasonable for a house contractor?

There is no specific rule for private house contracts in Indonesia. As a reference, public procurement caps the down payment and withholds part of the contract value as retention during the maintenance period. A safe principle: payments follow work actually installed.

Plan it right from the start

Tell us where your land is, its size, your architect or consultant (if you have one), and when you plan to start. Our team will review it and get back to you.